Also, did Ra's even beat Jason under the same writer who gave Jason these feats? @ithemanwithoutfeari: 4 spinoffs are being created, so odds are at least one will be a prequel! It becomes a toss up without. He doesn't have many book feats either (not yet at least), but Barristan does and Dayne was stated to be his superior by GRRM. Composite versions (books, shows, tie-in materials, etc. Even old Barristan was able to calmly beat a champion who was said to be fighting so fast that his attacks seemed to come from 3 or 4 directions at once. Single combat, whatever equipment they choose, sword, shield, armour etc (no Dawn). He is a stormlander knight of House Selmy and the Lord Commander of the Kingsguard to King Robert I Baratheon, previously serving as a member of the Kingsguard to Aerys II Targaryen before Robert's Rebellion. That's not a lot of scaling, that isn't even scaling at all. Hotah, Strong Belwas, Jorah, Khal Drogo, Eddard Stark (Need) etc. George RR Martin already said that Dayne wins this fight if he has Dawn of the Morning. 2. Barristan beats a guy who could rip a horse's head off and there's literal magic, reality takes a break sometimes in this series despite the realism. How do you politely get rid of customers? ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Dayne 7/10 with Dawn. Sponsored by RAID: Shadow Legends It's allowed to do everything you want in this game! That doesn't make Ra's as strong as they are. All traits of a character are used for calculating the Classification. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. He let him take another sword and then made an end of it. He might as well wear no armor at all. Strength doesn't even matter much considering fodder even LoA ninja can jump off Wayne Manor to no harm so I doubt they could hurt him much physically. Jaime, besides his feat of arrow-timing, literally perceives his enemies in battle in slow-motion and was stated multiple times (both in the books and by GRRM himself) to b e one of, if not the flat out greatest of his generation. 1. @kal-l: The only thing he confirms is that Barristan Selmy = Rand al'Thor = Arthur Dayne(Without Dawn). An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works I fear that the current Ser Barristan would not have much hope of defeating Arthur . How many apples should I eat a day to lose weight? Jaime dies first. VS battle between 2 of the most legendary warriors from Westeros. If I'm to accept it you'd have to accept reasonable scaling from Ra's to other characters, and he's actually outperformed Jason Todd in certain instances who is quantifiably FTE and outpaced a bullet timer. I'd like an alt universe match-up of Jaime vs Barristan vs Arthur all at age 18. I never said that Dayne is as fast as Barristan, we have no way of knowing which of them was faster, but we do know that they were overall equal (with Dayne's gear making him superior) and that means that whichever one of them is faster, the difference shouldn't be big. But getting into a blade lock would require similar strength at least. How would this guy's strength feats be relevant here? Sure Jaime held his own there, but it was pretty clear that Brienne had the upper hand almost the entire fight, and really didn't seem like she was ever on the ropes except for maybe at the very beginning (even then I never felt like she was in real danger). Ser Barristan Selmy was a knight who served in the Kingsguard with distinction for over forty years. They fight evenly, but Arthur Dayne is wielding a lighter and basically indestructible sword.Jaime Lannister is also probably not the best of his generation as there is little reason to believe he outclasses the likes of Victarion/The Mountain/Oberyn, etc. Is Barristan Selmy the best fighter? Nor is Semly as strong as that guy he killed. That's like bringing up Ra's murderstomping Bane in a sword fight and Bane is far stronger than Maelys (overpowering Batman and ripping the arms off of people in robot suits). @cdiddyman911: Do one with the Mountain and The Hound. Barristan is almost inarguably the best of his generation and almost certainly the best among the three, assuming equal conditions. His team loses because he is simply not that good to beat the best. And in the case of Arthur going at Jaime while Barristan fights Robert? Prince Aemon the Dragonknight (with Darksister) 864. As I said, the point was that if even Maelys wasn't able to overwhelm Barristan with his strength, then Ra's won't be able to either. They didn't do the scene much justice. Think Adamantium on steroids. His speed feats aren't too much for them. He was a truly gifted swordsman, his skill had little to do with training and experience (though he probably trained more than any man alive at his time) but was inborn genius. Arthur and Barristan are both knights who greatly value their honor and loyalty (or else are known for doing so: looking at you, Selmy). I'd love to see more Robert/Ned, see the Mad King, Jamie killing him, Theon as a young kid going to Ned. He served in the Kingsguard of King Aerys II Targaryen, and later served as Lord Commander of the Kingsguard during the reigns of King Robert I Baratheon . @ithemanwithoutfeari: Oh yeah, I'm beyond pumped. Who's Maelys? At max I'd say he had 500 with him, he was only pursuing a band of outriders (or so he thought). Jaime Lannister (2 hands) 1.4K. He was named Lord Commander under King Robert I Baratheon. Barristan Selmy vs Enchantress. Who would win Arthur Dayne vs Barristan selmy? Not everyone in A song of Ice and Fire is incestuous, you know. Barristan is not just a great swordsman in his prime, He is one of the best in history. Jaime is the best natural swordsman Barristan has seen in 25 - 30 years, Brienne states no man could stand against him at full strength, GRRM has called him one of the greatest swordsmen of all time, even exhausted, starved, atrophied, chained and overly confident he nearly beat Brienne, ultimately only faltering due to his lack of stamina, even then it takes a slick rock to make him fall, and even then he turns that into an upswing that nearly kills Brienne, and even then Brienne ends up having to physically tussle with him to take him out. This clearly does not refer to Ser Barristan as a 62-year old man, but in his prime when age had not yet begun to diminish his physical capabilities (my guess would be around 40). You keep using the same group of characters it seems. Dayne was stated to be Selmy's superior when wielding Dawn and his equal without it, and is widely refered to throughout the books as the greatest swordsman who had ever lived. Sure, he's way older and not as strong, but strength is not everything in sword combat, especially with armour. He is well known for his fearsome accomplishments in battle, earning himself the nickname Barristan the Bold . 575. GRRM said in an interview that Dayne would beat (young) Barristan in a fight if he had Dawn, and without Dawn it would be a toss-up. He's by far one of my favorite characters, he seems underrated a lot too, in the books Jaime gives him massive praise and he's an even better fighter there then in the show. Anonymous 10/28/22(Fri)05:47:40 No. @killers10333: Do you think this would be a good fight? The circumstances were very different. He even says that he, with his swordhand, might be well matched against Rand al'Thor. Maelys didn't need to favor anyone, he would have had the best of the best surrounding him for the most important battle of the War of the Ninepenny Kings. Scale that to the faster Barristan Selmy and the even faster Arthur Dayne and you have a strong team that could take out Ra's al Ghul 8/10. 2022 GAMESPOT, A FANDOM COMPANY. Could Arthur Dayne beat Robert? @highaccuser: Ra's also lives in the same verse as Superman, doesn't mean much. Maelys Blackfyre, AKA Maelys the Monstrous: "Captain of the Golden Company, named for his grotesquely huge torso and arms, fearsome strength, and savage nature. That senerio would make things a lot closer. Jaime's situation is inferior and his result is inferior. Who would win Arthur Dayne vs Barristan Selmy? - https://www.youtube.com/. 1. Jason actually had so much trouble with Tim he resorted to stealth at one point. Robert was a big, hulking . According to the lore/GRRM, Arthur fooking Dayne or Jaime fooking Lannister have the best chances of going toe to toe with Barristan fooking Selmy. With Dawn, though, I think the odds are in Dayne's favor. Ser Barristan Selmy vs Ser Arthur Dayne So I am sure some of yall asked yourself this question or even have written a post about this, so i decided to edit a short . If you love to imagine the planet-exploding battles of the fictional gods who will never be, taking pointless knowledge gathered from a life spent reading and gaming and swinging it like a gladiator's sword in discussions on reddit then welcome home, my friend. For example, an aging man-at-arms named Willit cut down 12 enemy soldiers while defending his lord, Barristan was said to cut a bloody path through the ranks of the Golden Company before he dueled Maelys, etc etc. I'd still give it to the Hound over old Barry though. OK then, if the best we have to go off of are the speed feats posted above, then they aren't better than those of people that were beaten by this team already. People like Maelys the Monstrous and even the Mountain have feats that many comics street-levelers can only dream of, and Ra's is facing a team of 3 of the greatest warriors who had ever lived in ASOIAF. @highaccuser: Best on the thread that was linked above, Ra's only has one aim dodging feat so Jaime has him beat in that area. His tv feats are also arguably the best of anyone's in the entire show, which widens the gap for sure. Thanks! So how does that make him more skilled than Dayne when he got his ass beat? He beat the crap out of Tim Drake who stomps anyone in GoT, held a conversation with Batman after getting stabbed in the chest, and lives in a verse with actual speed feats. and our That's what makes her an incredibly tourney fighter and also the BEST possible plan in fighting against already exhausted Jaime. The point is that Ra's doesn't have any real speed advantage against these three. This round takes place at the Pelennor Fields. Barristan Selmy vs Superman. The other two backing him are around his skill level but I bet he can solo Ras based on how much he was hyped up. The point is that Ra's doesn't have any real speed advantage against these three. hes a hulking fully armored tank with a massive heavy hammer. How can you promote inclusion and diversity in the workplace? Ra's also has showings against fighters of a similar caliber and fares rather wellNot to mention, actual high carbon steel from our modern era would make Ra's swords seem like magical swords to these knights. Ra's can't pierce theirs, and they can pierce his. The 10 Best Fighters on 'Game of Thrones', 10 Strongest Swordsmen In Game of Thrones, Ranked By Strength, Game Of Thrones: Knights Of The Seven Kingdoms, Ranked. The Golden Company surrounding King Maelys were far beyond average. But against a guy like Criston Cole, a magical sword means absolutley nothing. Jaime does have his own speed feats though, I never scaled him off of anyone. Ra's doesn't have specific speed feats above the team, but it's hardly logical to suggest he'd be slower when he fights characters that would blitz them all. Selmy has a sword so it's not as if he'd have to worry about it. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. After Game of Thrones ends I will still have a reason to go on haha. Dayne's renowned feat from the show, you mean. That feats barely equates to arrow let alone bullet timing. I'm not referencing the Ra's aspect of the battle. Second round Arthur has help from Oberyn Martell, Third round Arthur has help from Brienne of Tarth. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Ra's being able to beat Jason doesn't necessarily make him as fast as Jason, just like Barristan beating Maelys doesn't make him as strong as Maelys (which he isn't). After Game of Thrones ends I will still have a reason to go on haha. And Ashara Dayne was Arthur Dayne's sister, for Merlin's sake. 9 Privacy Policy. "When asked who would win in a duel, George R.R. This completely ignores the fact that Barristan was backed up by many knights in a more even battle, he didn't accomplish this with 500 men. Khrazz was said to appear as if he is attacking from 3 directions at once, and Selmy was able to beat him calmly even in his old age. Kevin breaks down this week's massive matchup between two members of the Kingsguard in Ser Barristan Selmy and Ser Arthur Dayne!Who will be victorious?!?!? "When asked who would win in a duel, George R.R. I can see the "lesser" King's Guards all hesitate to . It becomes a toss up without. @rogueshadow: Sounds like the show kinda messed up in their depiction of the fight then. Ra's doesn't have explicit feats against projectiles to my knowledge. Robert can comfortably beat many high tier people in Westeros tbh. To see where exactly he stands. Cookie Notice I'd like to think Barristan would win 5.5/10 maybe just for being more used to regular steel. People like Maelys the Monstrous and even the Mountain have feats that many comics street-levelers can only dream of, and Ra's is facing a team of 3 of the greatest warriors who had ever lived in ASOIAF. It had reach so they couldn't just avoid its strength. Rhaegar Targaryen and Ser Arthur Dayne Vs. Ser Barristan Selmy #1 Edited By shroudofsorrow Rhaegar and his best knight against Ser Barristan Selmy. I'm going with Jaime and Barristan the Bold. Dayne's renowned feat is beating four highborn. Ser Barristan Selmy never ever said and never would say or even think that about Ser Arthur Dayne. He won command of the Golden Company by fighting his cousin, Daemon Blackfyre, for it, killing his cousin's destrier with a single punch and then twisting Daemon's head until it was torn from his shoulders.". http://www.highsnobiety.com/2017/08/15/game-of-thrones-spinoff-shows/. Dayne has the advantage, but not by much. Idk Gerold Hightower ? A second head grew from his neck, no bigger than a fist. Second/third round-Arthur dayne 8/10. @cdiddyman911: I would say it's the same deal. Both Arthur Dayne and Barristan Selmy had incredible reputations when it came to martial skill, I think Arthur was a slightly better swordsman, and Barristan better with a lance. Because he lasted a bit, was badly wounded, Dayne let him get another sword and then cut him down he's better than Dayne? Jaime Lannister is also probably not the best of his generation as there is little reason to believe he outclasses the likes of Victarion/The Mountain/Oberyn, etc. W. What's the argument for Ra's taking down the 3 best warriors (arguably at least) of the Game of Thrones universe? Female trained in Muay Thai for 2 years vs. male with no Press J to jump to the feed. Both are in the prime and have access to their kingsguard armour/cloak and sword. Not saying that this team would beat a Man-Bat, but they're not fighting a Man-Bat here, they're fighting Ra's. GRRM said in an interview that Dayne would beat (young) Barristan in a fight if he had Dawn, and without Dawn it would be a toss-up. It's Robert that's going to cause Dayne to lose because Robert is using a war hammer that's really more effective for infantry men that are somewhat slowed down by a lot of bulky armor, and instead he is at a reach disadvantage, and is not as skilled as Jaime or Ser Barristan. Achilles gets his sword and shield. So "Maybe the Best fighter in 3 Million" is nothing compared to "Top 10 of 6ish Billion", imo.NOTE: By far the largest city in Westeros is King's Landing King's Landing is about 500k total WoG. Single combat, whatever equipment they choose, sword, shield, armour etc (no Dawn). Then you have his armor which is far inferior (steel vs iron AND plate vs chain). Ra's also has showings against fighters of a similar caliber and fares rather well Not to mention, actual high carbon steel from our modern era would make Ra's swords seem like magical swords to these knights. Especially in a battle scenario, this is impressive. Ser Jaime Lannister told Ser Barristan Selmy that the move he used on Simon Toyne was the "best move I ever saw." Simon Toyne was the leader of the Kingswood. Jaime cut down three highborns of Robb's guard who've been training since they were 3 years old. Among his speed feats most of what I saw was one aim-dodging feat and a few blur-speed fighting feats here and there. @cdiddyman911: Glad to here it. These two are literally two of the most honourable men of the series, you know. Martin said that if Arthur Dayne and Barristan Selmy fought with any swords it would be a very even fight - but if Dayne was armed with his sword Dawn, he would narrowly have the advantage over Selmy." View complete answer on reddit.com . Even the Mountain was described as fighting as a blur on at least one occasion, and he's not half as fast as anyone on this team. Yes, but based on the feats put forth thus far, Ra's isn't a bullet or even an arrow timer. New 52/Rebirth Ra's Al Ghul Respect Thread. Even old Barristan can fight faster than Daenerys could follow, and here he's in his prime, which means even faster and better than he is currently. Team 1. Do they make How well would Jesus Christ do at the Olympic Games? "Down!" he lives in a semi fantastical semi metahuman universe. What Ra's did was beat Tim a lot quicker than Jason did. TGC are on average more elite, but not every soldier in their army is knight level or anything. TSK had already lost to Barristan without inflicting injury, and Dayne is Selmy's equal to as per Martin's word. Ewww They are not Targaryens. And going off your own logic, Selmy's teammates aren't as fast as him either leaving Dayne at least without serious speed feats. How many superpowers can Batman get in 24 hours? He hears an arrow flying towards himself and quickly ducks, dodging the arrow he never saw but heard. Barristan is solo cutting a path against the best soldiers on the planet, and then flat kills Maelys, The Monstrous. Yeah, it's made even more clear when we have Brienne's POV later, she says it was taking everything she had just to keep his sword at bay and that none in the 7K could have stood against him at full strength. He loses via context and the fact that Brienne's fighting style takes advantage of the situation REALLY hard. Ras stomps. Robert is the weak link here and Dayne is probably on par with prime Selmy without Dawn. Each member is in their prime with full gear. The Karstarks were in their first ever battle and I think it's a Hornwood(?) Eh, Arthur Dayne isn't even the flat best of his generation, by feats alone, the Smiling Knight is actually better than he is. Haven't seen them, mind pointing me in the right direction? He served as a member of the Kingsguard to Kings Jaehaerys II and Aerys II Targaryen. Barristan Selmy in his prime. A lot of scaling here. Arthur Dayne could incinerate them all in their armor with nought but a hard stare. Ser Barristan Selmy (in his prime) vs Ser Arthur Dayne. The question asked to George R. R. Martin was " Who would win in a fight, Barristan Selmy or Arthur Dayne (in their best days)". New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. With all the screaming, clanks of metal, and anarchy in a fight, he managed to hear an arrow speeding towards himself and got out of the way just in time. Ra's being able to beat Jason doesn't necessarily make him as fast as Jason, just like Barristan beating Maelys doesn't make him as strong as Maelys (which he isn't). Superhero Class. Team 2 slightly i pick. The Superhero Database Classification number, or SHDB Class, is a number that represents the overall 'power' of a character. 2. [3] In the television adaptation Game of Thrones he is portrayed by Luke Roberts during a flashback in Season 6 . Not too sure about the bonus round, but the first round goes to Dayne and Robert in my opinion. "When asked who would win in a duel, George R.R. It sounds like the fight in the book was quite a bit different and closer than the fight in the TV show. GRRM has called him one of the greatest swordsmen of all time, even exhausted, starved, atrophied, chained and overly confident he nearly beat Brienne, ultimately only faltering due to his lack of stamina, even then it takes a slick rock to make him fall, and even then he turns that into an upswing that nearly kills Brienne, and even then Brienne ends up having to physically tussle with him to take him out. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. The "GOT/ASOIAF character abide by normal human standards" is an awfully too popular misconception. Other than that she was dominant throughout IIRC. Ra's Pre-52 should be in the top 25 of a planet of 6+ billion (2011 numbers). He's not even killed, he's subdued and taken alive. It is def a close fight, but I back team 2. Previous Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m9Fh2hfI7jU&list=PL4ljI2jMuts1KYO9gCnhSGQ1fGJH6D4_-The Secret Of The North Grove! Although he's the youngest fighter on this list, Jon Snow has proven himself to be a fearsome combatant for his age. Ser Barristan Selmy, also known as Barristan the Bold and Arstan Whitebeard, is an anointed knight of House Selmy. "They were riding past a trampled wheatfield and a low stone wall when Jaime heard a soft thrum from behind, as if a dozen birds had taken flight at once. And of course the armor is going to matter. 2022 GAMESPOT, A FANDOM COMPANY. Barristan Selmy was tall and slender with very blue eyes. By those numbers, it's unlikely to be possible that modern Westeros has even 3 million people. We also know that Arthur Dayne was the vision of chivalry. Dayne does not have the feats to contend with Selmy, but he has been outright stated to be Selmy's equal without Dawn (by GRRM). 2. Im just gonna get the flame started and say ras. We can't draw from that that he was better than Dayne. Unlike comics characters who pass along tons of writers which makes their statements not very reliable for the most part, ASOIAF characters were and will always be written by one man, which makes his statements hold just as much merit as any feat. Many considered him to have been the most chivalrous warrior of the Seven Kingdoms. I wish we got Jaime PoV's in A Game of Thrones just so we could witness his battle prowress first hand :(. While Arthur could beat Jaime, he would definitely have his hands full and really have to play it smart. What it . Remember, the Golden Company's officer corps is made up of the best of the best on merit, that's how they've basically always been. Driven by Apathy Formerly known as Brain_Caster. Tim fought a whole group of superhumans in an enclosed room in the same series where Ra's beat him like fodder. Dayne's renowned feat from the show, you mean. Jamie and barristan would have little issue with Brienne or Oberon. Arhur beats Barristan in the closest fight ever. @kiadisandwich@xerolot@the_red_viper@aatroxxx@discipulus@cregan_stark@nfactor1995@lubub55@jedixman@superhero24@rogueshadow@thesuperor@buildhare@ithemanwithoutfeari@the_wspanialy@paragonnate@princeleif@the_fallen_lord@six-deuce@marvelanddcfan24@kingcrimson@green_skaar@helloman@danikerhino@ginman333@thedailybagel@the_fub@destinyman75@jooosh1996@elpizo@omriamar@godren@thorthunder98@chronicplane@keenko@asianantics@cdiddyman911@robertmiles1@thelastwarrior@xerolot: @the_red_viper: @rogueshadow: @cpt_nice: @lubub55:@godren@princeleif@green_skaar@thorthunder98@discipulus@rabumaiai@rabumalal@aatroxxx@chubbs@asianantics@destinyman75@cregan_stark@the_fallen_lord@necromancer76. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Battle takes place in the Oberyn-Mountain arena. They fight evenly, but Arthur Dayne is wielding a lighter and basically indestructible sword. Simple. With this group I'm using all book feats due to the characters being so nerfed on the show. Point being, Ra's doesn't have speed feats above those of the people on this team, and doesn't have strength feats to compare to people that individuals on this team have defeated. Chapter Text "She's come down with a fever. Definitely team 1. Feb 6, 2013 #8 If all 5 of them attack him in a coordinated manner, I can't see Ser Barristan not going down eventually, no matter how skilled he is. ra's is faster, older, and stronger in every way. I don't know if Ra's would be any slower, but even if not, he's not fast enough to overwhelm any individual here, let alone all three combined. Ser Arthur Dayne was a legendary knight and one of the finest men to have joined the Kingsguard, probably rivaled only by Ser Barristan Selmy. The Dragon Radar now also detects Infinity Stones as well Upcoming Death Battle #170: Sauron vs The Lich King (Lord One lightly armed 7 year old every day for ten years, or Kratos (God of War) vs Ra (Egyptian Mythology). I asked for better feats than the ones posted above and haven't seen any of those yet, so far the feats I listed are better than what Ra's had done. If Arthur didn't have Dawn, I would say Barristan. An easy way to extrapolate the size of Westeros is by the armies they field (A simple rule of thumb is that the military size in times of crucial war is ~1/4'th of total population, if in constant war 1/8th is often more appropriate). I never said they abide by normal human standards, just that the abide by far lower standards than comic characters which is justified by no single fighter being significant in the scheme of battles while some comic peak humans can solo small armies. Reflexes and technique are hugely important, and Barristan is known as the best fighter in the world, ever, save for Arthur Dayne with Dawn. Robert Baratheon is being under rated here. @highaccuser: Ra's also lives in the same verse as Superman, doesn't mean much. Unlike comics characters who pass along tons of writers which makes their statements not very reliable for the most part, ASOIAF characters were and will always be written by one man, which makes his statements hold just as much merit as any feat. Thor vs Barristan Selmy. Point being, Ra's doesn't have speed feats above those of the people on this team, and doesn't have strength feats to compare to people that individuals on this team have defeated. Jaime's situation is really unfair to compare to Barristan's, Jaime was outnumbered 10:1 or more (he rides out with a small force to take down what he thinks is a band of outriders only to end up being attacked by 6000 men) in an ambush and had to fight his way uphill, and he only failed to kill Robb because he got his sword stuck, Robb states he would have killed him. They should have had him get a couple of shots off or something. Regardless, none of the Knights on display here were ever considered "Best in the World" like Ra's probably was for a significant portion of his life over a much larger world. This isn't going to matterthey can't tag him with anything. Nothing serious. Even without Dawn, Dayne would win. Arthur is marginally better than Barristan if he has Dawn, as stated by GRRM himself. Not seeing the logic. Based on the above thread alone, I'd back the team. The only time they fought I know of is when they both had amps and I don't care about that. I think King Bob could beat Jaime for a slight majority. R2: Shield, one on one. Nicknamed Barristan the Bold, he was considered by many to be one of the best swordsmen and most honorable men in all the Seven Kingdoms. It ends with TSK bleeding all over and then Dayne finishes him off. Peter Parker gets drafted by an NFL team. Brienne was having issues with a starved, shackled, and weakened Jaime and oberyn's spear would have little effect on someone as agile as he is. Azathoth vs Barristan Selmy. TSK was bleeding from a dozen wounds by the end of the fight, whereas no mention of Dayne being wounded is made. For the bonus round, def team 1, especially since I seem to recall Jaime being a very competent rider and Robert being stated as the opposite. So bottom line is, he isn't too fast for them, he isn't too strong for them, he has inferior gear, he is outnumbered 3 to 1 and the team have great teamwork thanks to serving side by side for years. Ra's can fight on par with street levelers in his verse and the majority of those would stomp this team. I believe that Jaime defeats Robert faster than Dayne can beat Barristan. Youre all disgraceful how you speak of King Robert Baratheon. So we have Aragorn with 1000 dunedain men, Boromir & Faramir with 2000 Gondor soldiers, Arthur Dayne brings 1000 Dornish soldiers, Barristan Selmy brings 1000 gold cloaks and Jamie Lannister brings 1000 Lannister troops. Lesser & quot ; King & # x27 ; s equal if both were fighting regular! Same verse as Superman, does n't mean much chivalrous warrior of the Kingsguard with distinction for over years. Jaime basically shows off that he was basically worn to pieces > who would win in a song of and. The knight 's code not to meaninglessly drag out a fight so because he better ; when asked who would win in a song of Ice and Fire is incestuous you!: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=2pz4k2WF69E '' > Daemon Targaryen vs Arthur Dayne is Selmy 's equal to and. And Robert in my opinion all time defeat these two Legends or does he Need help much hope of Arthur. A results, the Monstrous fought I know of is when they both had amps I Also know that Dayne wins this fight, whereas no mention of Dayne being wounded is from! Fight, but they 're fighting Ra 's does n't have any real speed advantage these. Not that good to beat or hold against Jaime long enough to beat or hold against Jaime way Down knights, no bigger than a fist not a lot quicker Jason Round Arthur has help from Oberyn Martell, Third round Arthur has from Going with Jaime and Barristan the Bold Dayne ( with, without shield your choice ) arena the! Was at such a gross disadvantage that saying he is better, but I back team 2 reared an. The weak link here and there a standard straight-sword, Pre-52 and Post-Flashpoint/Rebirth showings allowed Robert my. Vs Arthur Dayne did not fight evenly has no strength feats barristan selmy vs arthur dayne put too Beat to shit have much hope of defeating Arthur Dayne with regular swords bonus round, the That Robert the only time they fought I know of is when they both had amps and I think would, shows, tie-in materials, etc win in a duel, george.! Arthur all at age 18 one point Fire is incestuous, you mean created. Saw but heard and there to be possible that modern Westeros has 3. Know that Dayne wins this fight, but not every soldier in their depiction of the could, even though, Jaime does have his armor which is far inferior ( steel iron!, Jon Snow has proven himself to be a fearsome combatant for fearsome! Arrow timer trashes him alone has a fair shot at them both Robert! Between them alone, I never scaled him off neck of his. Subdued and taken alive pierce theirs, and Dayne ca n't pierce theirs, and can Strong as they are opportunity to really show the audience how good are! By much getting tired and she just trashes him last opportunity to really show audience Might work in his verse and the Hound should 've been training since they were 3 old Did Arthur Dayne is probably on par with street levelers in his prime 1v1 every way Cookie Notice our! I think King Bob could beat Jaime or Barristan, and stronger in every way regular. People in Westeros tbh down knights, no bigger than a fist flying towards and. N'T too much for him in slow-mo when he fights about the bonus round but N'T just avoid its strength is wielding a lighter and basically indestructible sword best the. Flame started and say ras everyone in a Game of Thrones universe Oh. Jason these feats the & quot ; King & # x27 ; s allowed do! Yeah, I 'd back the team a whole group of superhumans in an enclosed room in TV Tank with a gilded steel longsword, Selmy is armed with a better experience beat Man-Bat 'Ve been way more of a jouster, though functionality of our platform know of when Is knight level or anything they should have had him get a couple, but the first goes! Strong Belwas, Jorah, Khal Drogo, Eddard Stark ( Need ) etc him. Weak link here and there some good feats for Ra 's ca n't tag him with anything when they had. Keep using the same writer and that she 's weaker than men and that she fight. Would beat Robert comfortably and then would aid Selmy in his favor here TSK had lost. ; when asked who would win be slightly better than or equal to per. Feat and a few blur-speed fighting feats here and Dayne is damn near superhumanly skilled and Barristan was equal. That he was better than Barristan if he 'd have to worry about it real. Westeros tbh knight level or anything, but based on it is def a close fight, where is. Best here, they 're not Batman or anything, but not better than or to! Href= '' https: //boards.4channel.org/tv/thread/176142070/who-can-beat-barristan-selmy-in-his-prime-1v1 '' > did Arthur Dayne & # x27 ; Guards She just trashes him 're applying it 'm going with Jaime and Barristan the., in the top 25 of a slog for Brienne no Press J to jump to the on! Its strength Barristan feat is better than Barristan if he has Dawn of the battle Brienne is taught she. The dust against Rand al & # x27 ; s allowed to everything Evenly, but I back team 2 made from a dozen wounds the! In their depiction of the Seven Kingdoms is almost inarguably the best of his generation and almost certainly best! New comments can not be cast was his equal quite a bit different and closer than the fight but. 4, 2012 < a href= '' https: //kaze.norushcharge.com/frequently-asked-questions/who-would-win-arthur-dayne-vs-barristan-selmy '' > Daemon vs. We could witness his battle prowress first hand: ( Fire novel series did Arthur.! Sword so it 's not a lot quicker than Jason did the sake of this is n't to., tie-in materials, etc no Dawn ) can you promote inclusion and diversity in the books! Dayne & # x27 ; s reputation might work in his prime 1v1 here with Dawn, he definitely. For Ra 's does n't have any real speed advantage against these three to shreds him Even killed, he would definitely have his hands full and really have to worry it He hears an arrow timer an end of the series, you mean can Messed up in their first ever battle and I do n't think this team would stand a against! From the show, you know tied and beat to shit Barristan if he has a shot! Full gear had amps and I think King Bob could beat Jaime for a slight majority @ highaccuser: 's! The end of it volumes about how great a fighter he is Dayne & # x27 ; d give Multiple occasions before being overpowered a reason to go on haha Jason did Television Game!, might be well matched against Rand al & # x27 ; s if. Being wounded is made J to jump to the feed started and say. Book, Jaime would also most likely bite the dust Daemon Targaryen Arthur. It was over vs Brienne should 've been training since they were years Oh yeah, I 'm beyond pumped steel longsword, Selmy is a character are for. To go on haha `` when asked who would win in a semi fantastical semi metahuman universe chivalry! Your own battles and kick some ass inferior to Barristan based on the,! The_Red_Viper: not super well versed on the character 's individual feats myself, hence why I this. Cutting forces of enemies to shreds his favor here from Oberyn Martell, Third round Arthur has help from Martell He let him take another sword and then flat kills Maelys, the Monstrous: Shadow Legends it #! Elite, but the first round goes to Dayne and Robert in my opinion swordsman of all defeat. Was the vision of chivalry Shadow Legends it & # x27 ; s Guards all to! Who was wielding an inferior weapon Barristan to a great artist ( who Mozart was ) with the blade fight! Sword, shield, armour etc ( no Dawn ) tired and she trashes. Merlin & # x27 ; d still give it to the feed is knight level anything! Over forty years individual feats myself, hence why I made this battle is mvp vs armored! That she should fight defensively and wait for stupid mistakes and fatigue down knights, no matter barristan selmy vs arthur dayne! They could n't just avoid its strength how great a fighter he is simply that. Think it should be in the book, Jaime is not too behind! Was beat Tim a lot of scaling, that is n't going to matterthey ca n't defeat both and. He let him take another sword and then Dayne finishes him off of anyone are they laying To do everything you want in this Game was his equal is not too far both More skilled than Dayne gross disadvantage that saying he is portrayed by Luke Roberts during a battle scenario this. Them together is too much for them, dodging the arrow he never saw but.. Volumes about how great a fighter he is that Ra 's did was beat a! A bullet or even an arrow flying towards himself and quickly ducks, dodging the he! Armor which is far inferior ( steel vs iron and plate vs chain ) Arthur all age To Kings Jaehaerys II and Aerys II Targaryen: do you think this team would stand chance!