Clara's father tells journalists about the day they got the message of their daughter's death, how they had to identify the body, and take her home in a coffin. Privacy Policy | The documentary shows a series of short sequences depicting masses of people, emergency workers, police. In het gedrang vielen 21 doden en minstens 625 gewonden, waarvan enkele ernstig. "I sat there and cried," he recalls. In 2001, Germany's Constitutional Court revoked the Love Parade's classification as a demonstration. His plan was to bring the Love Parade to Germany's Ruhr area. "I have children of my own and as a police officer I want to make sure people are safe," he says. "For me the denial was as if Christian had died a second time," Gabi Müller told DW. Stirner points out that the "many mistakes made by police" are not addressed in the report. Telegram The hairdresser from the city of Hamm lost her only child in the tragedy, her 25-year-old son. ...de came up! Christian from Germany was 25 years old, Clara from Spain was 22 and Giulia from Italy was 21 — they were among the 200,000 young people attending the "Loveparade" techno music festival in the western city of Duisburg on July 24, 2010. The same scene as a density model. Jürgen Gerlach is a road safety expert. There was public anger against Mayor Adolf Sauerland,who was seemingly aware of substandard security provisions for the festival but pushed his administration to approve the plans anyway. The people in red are moving against the crowd. Public prosecutors and joint plaintiffs immediately lodged a complaint with the Higher Regional Court in Düsseldorf. In Germany, proceedings in the courtroom may not be filmed, so the makers of the documentary had actors read out testimonies from court documents and conducted interviews with observers. The organisers of Duisburg's Love Parade were yesterday accused of rejecting safety warnings on cost grounds before a stampede that left 19 revellers dead and injured more than 340 others. Why did kids have to die? Rainer Schaller Love-Parade-chief and manger for McFit the main sponsor of this event on the web-site of Love Parade Dortmund: “This is the Wonder of Dortmund: we have written history. Or are they furious because it lost? That is how a dangeraous scrum can come about. Legal notice | The 3D representation also shows people who are tall and those who are small. After almost half a million people flooded Berlin's Kurfürstendamm for the Love Parade in 1996, it became clear that a larger venue was needed. She wants to send a signal to survivors and victims: "We are asking for your forgiveness. Still, she says the case will send a signal that such a catastrophe must never be repeated: "Something good must come from the deaths of our children. There is often a crowd jam when the stadium is emptying up. They regularly bring her presents when they return from vacation and also decorate his grave: "He isn't forgotten and he has his place," explained Müller. The court failed to establish the individual defendant's criminal responsiblity, says prosecutor Uwe Mühlhoff. Ten people have been charged in connection with the deaths of 21 people at the Love Parade festival in the German city of Duisburg in 2010. A few months into proceedings he says that such a lengthy trial was  "real torture, not just for the victims, but also for the defendants.". Love Parade, Duisburg, Germany 24 July 2010, Love Parade was a popular and music festival/parade that was established in 1989 in Berlin, Germany. Although the parade itself got most of the media attention, the real point for the fans was the hundreds of parties in nearby clubs during the weekend, when nearly every major star of the electronic dance music world appeared. Der Oberbürgermeister von Duisburg, Adolf Sauerland, blieb wie angekündigt der Gedenkfeier fern. 46-year-old Judge Mario Plein is the top judge at Dusiburg court. Love Parade organizers made a pretty profit through licensing, advertising and merchandise sales. The Love Parade in Duisburg was the first to take place in a limited arena. For all its controversies, the main point of criticism directed at the festival was its increasing commercialization. Are the fans celebrating because their team won? The deaths occurred in a tunnel at the Love Parade in the city of Duisburg in the west of the country, where thousands had gathered for the annual techno music festival. That is why the researchers at Jülich compared different cultures: Germans, Indians, Chinese and Japanese. This ultimately forced the party to be cancelled in 2009, provoking outrage from seasoned ravers and parade-goers. Are there problems at the parking lots or with public transportation? Are they drunk? Het drama tijdens de Love Parade in Duisburg vond plaats op 24 juli 2010, toen honderden bezoekers van het dancefestival Love Parade bij de ingang van het feestterrein in de verdrukking kwamen. He stood accused along with five of his co-workers. Ten people are facing charges of negligence resulting in wrongful death and wrongful injury. Later he was unsettled by the thought that he actually watched people die, "but I couldn't see it," he says. Love Parade trucks could restart between 2006-2008 But in 2009-on the 20. th birthday of Loveparade, when the event was held in Bochum, the authorities once again cancelled the street parade. He says he is relieved that his objection to the district court's decision was a success. Twitter However, city officials refused, citing security concerns. The victims were crushed to death or suffocated when panic broke out in a congested tunnel at the Love Festival in the western city of Duisburg. The result was that Indians walk faster than Germans - maybe they also get crowd jams faster. By doing so, the computer models are very close to the real thing. In December 2017, more than seven years after the tragic Love Parade incident, prosecutors launched criminal proceedings against six Duisburg city employees and four festival organizers. By doing so, they were able to simulate large masses of people - not just with hundreds, but thousands of people. The parade features stages, but has floats with music, DJs and dancers moving through the audience. The experiment shows how people get distributed and whether they hamper themselves. She says that gives her much more solace than visiting the official memorial erected for victims in Duisburg: "I avoid that place.". Everyone wants to get home as quickly as possible after a football game. linkedin. How many vehicles should there be? which panic and the numbers bandied about, 250,000, 1,000,000 ,or even 1,400,000 of course,are nowhere visible. He confirms that there would have been a life-threatening congestion at the entrance of the tunnel even without the police cordoning off some of the routes. She says that at first she felt paralyzed but then she decided to sign an online petition that was attempting to draw attention to the case and help it get to court. No, Love Parade is definitely on July 24th. The Spanish-German documentary begins with a tracking shot through the tunnel to the festival venue, a former railway yard. Christian, Clara, Giulia, and the others were crushed to death here, they died of suffocation. If they do, it is part-time. It was held annually in Berlin from 1989 to 2003 and in 2006, then from 2007 to 2010 in the Ruhr region. Many survivors are still struggling with the effects of the catastrophe today and, like Gabi Müller, attend therapy and are unable to work. You can find more information in our data protection declaration. They all say they are happy that a turning point has now arrived, one that few expected. It remains unclear at this point what role a new, second expert report on the flow of visitors will play once the case gets underway. So how many people are heading to the same buses and trains can be calculated. "I am not seeking revenge," Christian's mother, Gabriele Müller, says on camera on the first day of the trial, she says she just wants to find out what happened so she could find her peace. A commission is to be established to rework the regulations for big events and come up with guidelines to facilitate the analysis of them — measures which lawyer Julius Reiter describes as "a necessary reaction to the disappointing end of the trial. But things are very different for someone in the crowd - people can hardly see what is happening a few meters away. Gabi Müller lost her only child, Christian, in the Love Parade disaster, "The response was overwhelming and it was comforting to see that so many people still remembered the tragedy," Müller said. The following year, the festival was moved to Berlin's Straße des 17. 2. authorization for the Mayor of Duisburg (OB)by the city parliament to sign frame contract with Lopavent GmbH for Loveparade in Duisburg in 2010, 11.06.2007, plus decision of city parliament of 20.02.2010 not to invest any public budget for the Loveparade 3. The ETH socio-physicist Dirk Helbing has examined why the Love Parade in Duisburg, two years ago, ended in disaster. Hundreds of thousands of techno music fans attended the Love Parade, which ended in tragedy after panic broke out in a tunnel that served as the event's entrance. Hannelore Kraft, who was premier of North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW), the state where Duisburg is located, promised solemnly to establish who was responsible. The Love Parade was part of the Ruhr's post-industrial coming-out party. "For me this is about clarification. On July, 24th 2010 there was a severe incident at the love parade in Duisburg, Germany. Contact the Love Parade relaunched in 2006, bringing more than a million revelers to Berlin. [51] for a collection of links). Twenty-one people were killed, hundreds injured. Germany Love Parade disaster: Looking those responsible in the eye. Mountains of garbage in the Tiergarten became a common sight, to the disgust of many locals. Christian's, Clara's, and Giulia's parents were among the 60 co-plaintiffs in the trial that began in 2017, in which six city officials and four representatives of the festival organizer LopaVent were charged with negligent manslaughter and causing bodily harm. "I want to look into the faces of the defendants and see what kind of people they are." "It will not be possible to assign guilt to specific individuals," said Cologne criminal defender Kerstin Stirner. Il disastro della LoveParade è una tragedia avvenuta il 24 luglio 2010 nel corso della diciannovesima edizione della LoveParade svoltasi a Duisburg in Germania in cui morirono 21 persone e ne rimasero ferite altre 510.. The computer calculates certain formulas, which are later incorporated into models. According to the Duisburg District Court, the main file alone consists of 117 folders containing some 53,000 pages. ", © 2021 Deutsche Welle | That means more safety at the emergency exits and escape routes. The legs are otherwise in the way. There was public anger against Mayor Adolf Sauerland. Roeingh said he wanted the festival to be seen as a protest for peace. from t-online July 25 2010 In April 2017, the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf ordered the Duisburg District Court to move ahead with the trial. Cries from the injured and the families of the dead. Victims' families are counting on justice. As the number of party-goers increased, so did the number of artists and event organizers who brought their own floats, or "love mobiles," to the parade. DUISBURG, Germany — Throngs of techno fans followed the floats, the dancers and the throbbing music to the festival venue: an old freight railway station that local media estimated could handle 300,000 people. Several people, however, have claimed that the numbers were massively inflated by organizers, likely for marketing purposes. A new documentary sheds some light on the matter. Right before the tenth anniversary of the tragedy, the NRW parliament voted to increase the compensation payments for the victims. Those are exactly the reasons Gabi Müller wants to be in the court when the trial begins. High on the festival's successes in Essen and Dortmund, organizers wanted to bring the Love Parade to the city of Bochum in 2009. (25.07.2010), © 2021 Deutsche Welle | Every year on July 24, Germany comes together to commemorate the victims of the festival tragedy. She read out all 21 names of the victims. Protocol 25.09.2009 of meeting with city authorities, Lopavent, Aurelis 4. The red lines show it - only 20 centimeters more are enough to offer freedom to move. Almost eight years after 21 people died and 650 were injured at the "Love Parade" music festival in Duisburg, the incident is finally being reviewed in a court of criminal law. Some 150 party-goers, followed by three cars blaring techno music, danced down Berlin's Kurfürstendamm boulevard under the banner "Peace, joy and pancakes.". ", "If guilt can not be proven in court, that does not mean there is no moral responsibility," former NRW State Premier Hannelore Kraft said in parliament that day. The Love Parade was part of this “image” campaign, and in the past few years was held in the Ruhr cities of Essen and Dortmund, and was scheduled for 2011 in Gelsenkirchen. The region had been the soot-coated centre of Germany's coal and steel … It is clearly visible how people moving in opposite direction hamper each other. The court determined the report lacking in legal substance, adding that much of the evidence it presented was of little use in the case. Due to the scale of the event estimated attendance However, because the Love Parade was still, in theory, a political festival, Berlin's state government had to bear the costs, both for security and for the mass clean-ups. The fenced-in venue with the narrow entrance and exit were simply not suitable for such an event, he concludes. Such factors cannot be easily simulated by the researchers. People were crushed, fell to the ground and trampled to death. Dressler is the only high-ranking city official who ended up in the dock. In an effort to prevent people from entering the overcrowded site, police at the exit of the tunnel began instructing new arrivals by loudspeaker to turn back inside, while people continued pushing on into the confined space from the rear. It will be an enormous undertaking. Loveparade Duisburg † 24. July 24, 2010, was a sunny Saturday. Or are they in a hurry because they want to get on their train? He says the pictures showed events that should never have taken place. In the image, people are moving in opposite directions above, and with each other below. Judges in the city determined that there was a "reasonable probability" of a conviction in the case. Who is responsible for this tragedy, which took place in Germany, a country with high safety standards? Jürgen Dressler headed the construction department of the city of Duisburg in 2010. The Trial" has been released. At the entrance ramp to the festival area, 21 persons died in a crowd crush and many were injured. the Love Parade in Duisburg and the planning beforehand. 21 people died as concertgoers became trapped under this tunnel in Duisburg. He says there had been "organized irresponsibility" around the event in Duisburg, where many people were involved in the planning, but in the end, it was totally unclear who was actually responsible for what. They all had to walk in circles. According to the Love Parade organizers, more than a million flocked to the city of Essen for the first edition of the festival in western Germany in 2007, while some 1.6 million people partied in Dortmund the following year. Love Parade, tunnel disaster: Location: Duisburg, Düsseldorf Government Region, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany : Point in time: 24 July 2010: Start time: 24 July 2010: End time: 24 July 2010: Number of deaths We use cookies to improve our service for you. When another officer said she could see dead bodies, he thought she must be mistaken. No one has been held accountable after a trial ends without a verdict. On 24 July 2010, a stampede at the 2010 Love Parade electronic dance music festival in Duisburg, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany, caused the death of 21 people.At least 510 more were injured. Researchers from the Jülich Research Center (Forschungszentrum Jülich) want to find out how crowd flows are formed to make large events safer. The festival coincided with the city's selection as a European Capital of Culture and attracted over a million visitors. The Love Parade (German: Loveparade) was a popular electronic dance music festival and technoparade that originated in 1989 in West Berlin, Germany. Facebook Organizers ended the event after a tragic stampede at the 2010 Love Parade in Duisburg killed 21 and injured more than 500. The paths that they leave are displayed as lines. Loveparade will be organized in 2010 and 2011 in Duisburg if nothing comes up. The coronavirus' impact on public life made an already tight timetable untenable, the court said. In 2010 The Love Parade moved to Duisburg the first time the festival had been held in an enclosed space; previous events had been held in open streets and parks. There was a stampede in one of the entrance tunels and at least 15 people died and more than 100 have been injured, many of them very seriously. This is how they created an intense chronology of the trial. In this experiment, the researchers recorded the crowd flows in a regular stadium block. The weather attracted large numbers of mostly young people who simply wanted to have fun and dance to music. reddit Kondolenzbuch http://kondolenzbuch.loveparade-duisburg-jahrestag.de After almost two years of deliberation, the Duisburg District Court refused to allow the main proceedings to move forward. The NRW state interior minister stood by the police force, assigning all the blame to the organizer's security concept and the festival personnel. The difference is very low, but while only 42 people were able to go through the narrow corridor, 50 through the wide corridor. Twenty-one men and women from Germany, Australia, China, Italy, The Netherlands, and Spain lost their lives when they were crushed to death in a narrow tunnel leading to the site. Witnesses say that there was such a large number of people in the tunnel that many were trapped and could no longer breathe. [1]The Love Parade was a popular and free access festival and parade that originated in 1989 in Berlin. Years of torture for parents and defendants. He says it means a lot to him to be able to speak in court because he wants to tell the victims he's sorry. He recalls looking down from the top of a staircase thinking it looked "dangerously crowded, but not deadly.". Their movements are recorded mathematically. 652 were injured, many more left traumatized. On Friday, the first of 111 scheduled days of court testimony will commence. Since the stadium stands are skewed, the cameras record the move of the people in 3D. Panic broke out as crowds converged in a tunnel leading to the festival grounds, resulting in the deaths of 21 people, and injuring a further 650. She thinks it quite possible that no one will be found to have been clearly guilty. This includes the planning documents [49], the event log of the regulatory au-thority of the city of Duisburg [52], and the evacuation analysis [53]. They interviewed victims, judges, prosecutors, defense lawyers, expert witnesses, defendants for their documentary, which offers a multi-faceted view on this legal endeavor to establish facts and responsibility. Director Dominik Wessely says he couldn't find any easy answers. Juni (17th of June Street), with the Victory Column, Brandenburg Gate and Tiergarten Park providing a historic backdrop to the frenzied techno rave. To coincide with the 10th anniversary of the tragedy, the new documentary "Loveparade. None of the involved organizations or officials took the blame for the disaster; instead, they accused each other: The festival organizer accused the police of mistakes in crowd control. We use cookies to improve our service for you. The people are pushing through the exit. Publicly | Mobile version. It will likely be one of the largest criminal cases in Germany since the end of the Second World War. Here is a chronology of events that led to the incident. How could this be? Since organizers did not want to bear the security or clean-up costs, the 2004 and 2005 Love Parade festivals were cancelled. She also gains strength from the support of her son's friends. When in May 2020, the trial ended without a verdict, the court issued a 44-page document explaining that it had not been possible to prove the criminal responsibility for any of the individual defenders. Torsten Meyer was one of them. Clara's parents, Francisco Zapater und Nuria Caminal, have traveled from Tarragona in Spain. ", Matthias Roeingh, better known by his stage name Dr. Motte, organized the first Love Parade in Berlin in 1989 along with fellow DJs Jonzon, Westbam and Kid Paul.