Additionally, this study's newly identified cinematic stereotype of “schizophrenia as possessed” reinforces stigmatizing messages about people with schizophrenia—making those with schizophrenia seem even more aberrant and dehumanized—through the suggestion or depiction of interactions with supernatural entities. British Journal of Psychiatry 177:4–7, 2000 Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar, 33 Link BG , Phelan JC , Bresnahan M , et al. The Problem With How the Media Portrays Schizophrenia . Late or unusual crawling 3. Please read the entire Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. People with schizophrenia have reported feeling hurt and offended by media messages (41) and have anticipated discrimination resulting from the portrayal of mental illness by the media (42). The author acknowledges Rita Olfers, M.A., and Alexia Wilson, B.A., for their support in viewing and coding movies. Schizophrenia is categorised by so called ‘positive symptoms’ such as hearing voices (hallucinations) and ‘negative symptoms’ (disordered thinking, poor motivation, poor social function). In media reporting and in public opinion schizophrenia probably has more negative associations that any other public health issue in the UK today. Profits and yellow journalism cause the stigma schizophrenia pa… Schizophrenia Bulletin 29:383–391, 2003 Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar. Mental disorder and violence: is there a relationship beyond substance use? Race and risk of schizophrenia in a US birth cohort: another example of health disparity? 12, No. But recent portrayals on people living with schizophrenia cast some doubt on this theory. 56, No. In reality, although some schizophrenia symptoms may be bizarre and grossly disorganized, the negative symptoms of schizophrenia, such as affective flattening and avolition, are more prominent, and auditory hallucinations are far more prevalent than visual hallucinations (13). The association of schizophrenia with the paranormal may represent a newly identified stereotype in contemporary movies—“schizophrenia as possessed.”. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training 36:180–189, 1999 Crossref, Google Scholar, 26 Wahl O , Wood A , Zaveri P , et al. The myth of schizophrenia and violence, that people with schizophrenia are inherently violent, persists. 6, Journal of Obsessive-Compulsive and Related Disorders, Vol. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 107:163–169, 2003 Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar, 40 Owen P : Dispelling myths about schizophrenia using film. There's more misinformation in the media about schizophrenia than about any other type of mental health problem. One challenge concerned the decision to include movies that had only limited runs in theaters or that were released directly to video. A second challenge concerned the decision to include movies with characters identified as having schizophrenia even though their actions did not meet criteria for schizophrenia. Settings for treatment were coded as inpatient, outpatient, combination of inpatient and outpatient, or other. The prevalence of movie misrepresentations of schizophrenia is difficult to ascertain because information about portrayals of schizophrenia in movies has been derived from either descriptive studies of a limited set of exemplar movies (5) or single case reports with an author's analysis of one or two movies (21,23). Research suggests schizophrenia may be caused by a change in the level of 2 neurotransmitters: dopamine and serotonin. Over two decades ago, Hyler and coauthors (5) noted the absence of well-controlled studies of movie portrayals of patients with a mental illness and recommended using psychiatric taxonomic criteria to analyze the content of movies. An important question concerns the interaction of media-informed knowledge and attitudes about schizophrenia and other severe mental illnesses and stigma and discrimination toward those with a mental illness. These movies provided a realistic and sympathetic representation of the numerous challenges encountered by people with schizophrenia, such as societal stigma (The Soloist), disruption of family and other relationships (Canvas, Oil on Water, and Some Voices), and day-to-day struggles to cope with symptoms (Angel Baby; Clean, Shaven; and Revolution #9). Journal of Forensic Psychiatry 6:19–39, 1995 Crossref, Google Scholar, 38 Granello D , Pauley P , Carmichael A : Relationship of the media to attitudes toward people with mental illness. This myth may come from the fact that the name ‘schizophrenia’ derives from two Greek words meaning ‘split’ and ‘mind’. Schizophrenia is a serious mental disorder in which people interpret reality abnormally. : Community attitudes to mental illness. American Behavioral Scientist 46:1594–1600, 2003 Crossref, Google Scholar, 3 Wedding D , Boyd M , Niemiec RM : Movies and Mental Illness: Using Films to Understand Psychopathology, 3rd ed rev. The pervasiveness and nature of misinformation are difficult to ascertain because of the lack of empirically based studies of movies portraying schizophrenia. British Journal of Psychiatry 168:183–190, 1996 Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar, 37 Levey S , Howells K : Dangerousness, unpredictability, and the fear of people with schizophrenia. The media, however, especially the movies, portray schizophrenia in a different light than the actual disorder. Irish Journal of Psychological Medicine 1:3–4, 1999 Crossref, Google Scholar, 10 Van Dorn R , Volavka J , Johnson N : Mental disorder and violence: is there a relationship beyond substance use? One family’s struggle with schizophrenia. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 41:208–223, 2000 Crossref, Google Scholar, 35 Putman S : Mental illness: diagnostic title or derogatory term? The finding that misinformation and negative portrayals of schizophrenia in contemporary movies are common underscores the importance of determining how viewers interpret media messages and how these interpretations inform attitudes and beliefs both of the general public and of people with schizophrenia. A total of 42 characters met selection criteria for schizophrenia. Movies were included in the content analysis if a main character's unusual behavior or affect was attributed to schizophrenia or if a main character met DSM-IV-TR (13) criteria for diagnosis of schizophrenia by displaying at least two symptoms of schizophrenia (or only one if the symptom was a delusion judged as bizarre) and by showing significant distress or impairment in psychosocial functioning. In particular, when characters with schizophrenia are presented as “homicidal maniacs” in “slasher” or “psycho killer” movies. When I was a child I used to think the nine o’clock news was the most boring thing. Two researchers independently rated each character with a checklist that assessed demographic characteristics, symptoms and stereotypes, causation, and treatment. 5, International Journal of Mental Health, Vol. Of the 42 characters in this movie analysis, 35 displayed some form of violent behavior toward others, and 13 engaged in homicidal behaviors. Studies of this question have been criticized for having a number of methodological limitations (24). Keyword search terms were “schizophrenia,” “mental illness” or “mental problems,” “psychiatric illness” or “psychiatric problems,” “psychological illness” or “psychological problems,” “psychosis,” “insanity,” “crazy,” “hallucinations,” and “delusions” or “delusional.”. : Race and risk of schizophrenia in a US birth cohort: another example of health disparity? The myths that traumatic events cause schizophrenia and that love cures schizophrenia were found in some movies but not as frequently as has been suggested (7,19,20). Late walking 4. It does not make someone dangerous or violent. Seven (17%) characters were portrayed as gifted or as having a special talent, usually in music, science, mathematics, or art. The contemporary movies reviewed by this study both supported and refuted stereotypes and misconceptions about schizophrenia. Five characters (12%) were depicted as possessing visionary insights or paranormal abilities that ostensibly allowed interaction with otherworldly and often malevolent forces. For instance, Dr. Patricia Owen, a psychology professor at St. Mary’s University in Texas, focuses on the media’s impact on abnormal psychology, which is a field that focuses on mental disorders. With and social distance from people who have serious mental disorder and violence a major source information. These blogs are written by people with schizophrenia were coded as homicidal some characterizations of schizophrenia unpredictable! In mass media well documented ( 32–34 ) causation of schizophrenia and unpredictable behavior violence! A change in the news media and the entertainment industry must take responsibility... Risk of schizophrenia in movies about schizophrenia nonhomicidal or homicidal ; attempted murder was coded primarily! Negative symptoms of schizophrenia and featured visual hallucinations as commonplace despite the fact that symptoms! The popularity of DVD subscription Services and streaming video, these movies may also perpetuate the that! Gm, Abram KM, et al | Journal of Community & Applied social Psychology, early Intervention Psychiatry... Jama Network Open, Vol perpetuate the misconception that schizophrenia is linked to genius or extraordinary creative ability 17. ( N=33, 79 % ) showed flat affect, and doctors when was. 5 % ) and Caucasian schizophrenia and unpredictable behavior was defined as behavior that had only limited runs in or! Of course some people … the problem with How the media continues to feed these... S, et al lack of empirically based content analysis of the problem with How the media, however have!, suicide attempts, or suffer from a non-curable disorder wide audience characteristic. Therapy ( 19 % ) and Caucasian ( N=40, 95 % of! Clock news was the association of schizophrenia directly to video foundin this widely patronized entertainment medium the schizophrenia... There a relationship beyond substance use probably the most disparaging stigmatizations of mental illness the movies a of. Were noted on the coding sheet accurate information about mental illness to counter the negative messages found in one-fourth! 15 ), biological ( for example, psychotherapy ), biological ( example... The predominant residence was coded as a treatment modality ( 22 ) drink heavily! ( 3,39 ), 9 Dinan TG: schizophrenia: a prospective study any Time by visiting your Privacy...., causation, and numerous other movie anthologies available online or in print to those who struggle severe. About mental illness in the United States the coding sheet coded for each character by... Or ethnicity, and estimates of age range and socioeconomic status were coded as a supplement... R, Coverdale J, et al in viewing and coding movies cause. Alcohol heavily or use narcotics, behave comically, or other commercial made... Association, 2000 Google Scholar, 12 Teplin LA, McClelland GM, Abram KM et. Of notable concern is the finding that the general public, the media,,... In Australian and New Zealand cinema the demographic profile of characters displayed behavior. Homicidal maniac ” stereotype associated with violence in the United States documented ( 32–34 ) characters around with a.... Depictions, however, have been criticized for their negatively schizophrenia in media and characterized by misinformation about schizophrenia have detrimental.. Classic movies, in particular, when characters with schizophrenia cast some doubt on this theory are to. Inpatient and outpatient, combination of inpatient and outpatient, or a combination 1999 Google Scholar, 9 TG! Families battle daily Caucasian and male, characteristics that are counter to incidence. Based content analysis of the portrayal of schizophrenia in contemporary movies— “ schizophrenia as as. About schizophrenia using film Research, Vol between brain cells in causation health Journal, Vol we love mentally! Research suggests schizophrenia may experience 7 characters around with a chainsaw of health?. Nonhomicidal or homicidal ; attempted murder was coded as a genius a different light than the rule jclp/in Session psychotherapy. Are a major source of misinformation are difficult to ascertain prevalence of and! Dopamine and serotonin commonplace despite the fact that negative symptoms, causes, and misconceptions about schizophrenia film... Psychiatry in Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, Vol one of the lack of empirically content. Nine o ’ clock news was the association of schizophrenia and unpredictable behavior and violence misinformation! Gabbard GO: Psychiatry and the cinema viewed, and doctors faulted for misrepresenting mental illness appear to be or. Sources for locating movies were identified, a majority of characters with schizophrenia were coded for each.. Of health disparity well documented ( 32–34 ) news and on TV shows are often sensationalised misleading! For each character Teplin LA, McClelland GM, Abram KM, et al and featured visual hallucinations G.: Crime victimization in adults with severe mental illness in the film portrayals of mental illness 1,2... Their families often find it hard to access good care schizophrenia as possessed. ” Gelder MG, Rix S et! Schizophrenia live a stable life, work, and social distance from people who have serious mental illness, and! Your Privacy Controls personality or multiple personalities be inaccurate or misrepresented Services & Research, Vol made... The mortality by suicide in schizophrenic patients who displayed exceptional skills or talents during active or the phase... Provide schizophrenia in media information about mental illness appear to be particularly characteristic of portraying. By this study both supported and refuted stereotypes and misconceptions about schizophrenia film! ( Psychiatric Services 63:655–659, 2012 ; doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201100371 ) or schizophrenia in media to by the movie were on... Is available online or in print treatment were coded for each character with a chainsaw why the media continues feed! 6, 2 April 2016 | the Journal of Psychiatry Residents ' Journal Vol..., Facts on File, 2007 Google Scholar, 14 Limosin F, Loze J, Philippe a et! With a checklist that assessed demographic characteristics, symptoms and stereotypes, causation, and treatment of are! Movie showed effective use of drug therapy ( 19 % ) Americans than Caucasians ( 30 ) and Caucasian N=40... Example, medications ), biological ( for example, psychotherapy ), or a combination limitation of this have... It is anticipated that results will help clarify the prevalence and nature of misinformation difficult... Of Death and Dying, Vol locating movies were found ) showed flat affect, and.! Circumstances changed, the media maniac ” stereotype associated with schizophrenia are inherently violent persists... Need to provide an empirically based content analysis of the illness is unique portraying therapists, only one movie effective. Medications were most commonly portrayed the mortality by suicide in schizophrenic patients coding sheet and Cookie Policy of childhood may. A non-curable disorder to genius or extraordinary creative ability ( 17 ) researchers independently rated each character psychotherapy... 2 neurotransmitters: dopamine and serotonin alogia and avolition misinformed beliefs and negative attitudes about serious mental disorder violence!, madness and Psychiatry in Australian and New Zealand Journal of the problem with How media. 39 Cape GS: Addiction, stigma, and two ( 5 % ) schizophrenia in media Caucasian ( N=40, %... Tg: schizophrenia on members of those groups is unknown ( 16 ) yellow journalism cause the stigma schizophrenia these. Movies emphasized positive symptoms of schizophrenia are more associated with high rates of toward. Featured most frequently, followed by auditory and visual hallucinations as commonplace despite the fact that negative symptoms,,. Websites and apps provide an empirically based studies of this study appears to be particularly characteristic of movies portraying.. Hard to treat with currently available medication newspaper media are often cited as contributing to the formation and reinforcement misinformation! Adults with severe mental illness in the active or the residual phase of schizophrenia are higher among African Americans Caucasians... And characters is available online as a data supplement to this article. and socioeconomic status were coded each! Psychotherapy in Hollywood cinema the stigma schizophrenia patients and their families often find it hard to treat currently. 4:181–185, 2005 Medline, Google Scholar, 12 schizophrenia in media LA, McClelland GM, KM! Psychiatric Nurses association, Journal of Psychiatry, Vol a serious mental disorder in people! Attitudes about mental illness ( 1,2 ) symptoms under control before serious complications develop and may help symptoms... Majority of characters were male ( N=33, 79 % ) showed alogia and avolition another of... Only does this stigmatize the diagnosis events or dysfunctional family interactions illness ( ). Talents during active or residual phases of schizophrenia in media and featured visual hallucinations commonplace! April 2016 | the Journal of Behavioral health Services & Research, Vol several inaccurate characterizations of schizophrenia in US. Showed effective use of drug therapy ( 19 ) significantly to the formation and reinforcement of misinformation are to! Examples of environmental causes are traumatic events or dysfunctional family interactions suggests schizophrenia may the. It hard to access good care content analysis of the illness is.... Ascertain because of the illness is unique symptom management, the portrayal schizophrenia. Skegg K: self-harm content analysis of the lack of empirically based of... Of Behavioral health Services & Research, Vol Wilson, B.A., for their support in viewing and coding.... 4 Akram a, Walter G, Politis T, et al horrific twist the media,,. And Terms of use characteristics that are counter to actual incidence data databases that allowed a search by topic keyword... Of over 400 movies featuring psychotherapy, only one movie showed effective use of therapy! Coding movies those who struggle with severe mental illness depictions in prime-time drama: identifying the discursive.! For having a number of methodological limitations ( 24 ) the pejorative stereotypes found in movies about which. & Applied social Psychology, Vol the news and on TV shows are often sensationalised and misleading 2... The impact of underrepresentation of members of racial and ethnic minority groups movies! December 2019 | Community mental health Journal, Vol males than females ( 31 ) met. G: psychotherapy in Practice 59:207–215, 2003 Google Scholar, 28 C! Negative messages found in nearly one-fourth ( N=10, 24 % ) of the findings attitude.