Rather, New Jersey business law imposes a "duty of good faith and fair dealing" on every party to a contract. Parties to a contract may be bound to exercise the discretion afforded them under the contract by the contractual duty of good faith and fair dealing. With that said, the doctrine cannot be used when the conduct in question is specifically addressed in the contract, nor can it be used to rewrite the terms of the contract. This is important because even if your contract does not explicitly require you to cooperate or if your contract does not explicitly state that you must not interfere, the duty of good faith and fair dealing may require you to do so or else you risk breaching the agreement. For example, if one party has a history of being difficult in its performance of contractual obligations, but is by letter of the law compliant nonetheless, a court may rule that the party asserting a breach of implied duty should have reasonably foreseen issues and rule that no breach occurred. Thus, they will have violated the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. Definition. Ct. Com. [4] In other words, a court may not use the doctrine to recognize any obligations that negate an unrestricted contractual right authorized by an agreement or prohibit conduct that the contract authorizes. Her role entails writing legal articles for the law library division, located on the LegalMatch website. Every state has a way to enforce this duty to ensure that business runs smoothly but there is no uniform standard on how states determine a breach of contract. Nova Contracting, Inc. v. City of Olympia, No . When a party contracts to purchase a home, gets denied by a mortgage company, and then refuses to use a different mortgage company in order to go through with the sale. The implied duty does not bestow new rights upon parties to a contract, but rather requires contracted parties to act in a reasonable manner when performing or enforcing their contractual rights. We've helped more than 5 million clients find the right lawyer for free. Your The implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing imposes reciprocal duties on both parties to a contract. The New Jersey Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act (NJ-RULLCA) includes a contractual obligation of good faith and fair dealing: "A member shall discharge the duties under this act or under the operating agreement and exercise any rights consistently with the contractual obligation of good faith and fair dealing." N.J.S.A. Oftentimes, such cases will be determined based on the individual facts of that case. In such a situation, the nature of a previous relationship could define the scope of implied duty in the following relationship. What recourse do you have? No. If you are involved with a claim based on a violation of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, or any other contract-related issue, then you should contact a contract lawyer in your area for assistance. And like other contracts, employment contracts can be enforced if the contract is breached. According to the laws governing contracts, all contracts include the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. This duty requires that neither party will do anything that will destroy or injure the right of the other party to receive the benefits of the contract. The implied duty of good faith and fair dealing is a pillar of the Uniform Commercial Code. Nor can the implied duty be used modify or vary the "specified, unambiguous terms of a contract.". (2000) 24 Cal.4th 317, 349-350.) [19] The founders were eventually terminated a month before they were owed additional consideration. The Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing The Restatement (Second) of Contracts (Restatement) further advanced the application of the duty of good faith and fair dealing to all contracts. (citing Amirsaleh v. Bd. Having no intent to complete a contract or engaging in a contract that is unreasonable or deceitful The Plaintiff suffered injury due to the Defendant's conduct. This duty is sometimes referred to as the implied duty of good faith and fair dealing. [21] In doing so, the court noted that even though contracts often grant wide or unfettered discretion to one party, the law presumes that parties never accept the risk that their counterparties will exercise their contractual discretion in bad faith.[22]. Dec. 22, 2021) (citing Dunlap, 878 A.2d at 442). Depending on the circumstances, the breaching party might also be responsible for paying other kinds of consequential damages that the non-breaching party incurred as a result of the breach. It is important to keep in mind, however, that substantial performance issues are tricky to litigate and the court will likely consider other factors before discharging the parties contract. Courts presiding over breach of implied duty claims have the ability to imply obligations in contracts outside of a contracts express provisions. [7] Ultimately, the court found that an implied covenant could not be breached because the contract specifically entitled the defendants to make demands of Pacira related to the satisfaction of milestones and Pacira was required to respond. While in law school, her law journal note was selected for first-round publishing, and can be found on various legal research databases. 2005). As a result, you are unable to pay your franchise fee. When one of the parties to a contract violates the covenant of good faith and fair dealing, it will be considered a breach of the contract. Typically, courts find that a party breaches this rule when they act in ways that obviously undermine the benefits to the other party from the contract or if one party attempts to sabotage another in performing their end of the agreement. Contractors dealing with the government at almost any stage of contract performance would do well to give serious thought to the duty of good faith and fair dealing. 619.221.4400 Book Consultation. Generally, any claims related to a breach of contract must be brought within ten (10) years (written contract) or eight (8) years (oral contract) from the date . [3] Dunlap v. State Farm Fire and Cas. See 671.203, Fla. Stat. The law imposes this duty of good faith and fair dealing to facilitate performance and enforcement of contracts. 42:2C39(d). Most jurisdictions, including Texas in limited situations, recognize that parties to a contract are bound by an implied duty of good faith and fair dealing in both the performance and enforcement of a contract. N20C-12-181, 2021 WL 6068215, at *9 (Del. Neither concept turns on "a court's belief about what was morally or equitably appropriate under the circumstances" but rather "on the contract itself and what the parties would have agreed upon had the issue arisen when they were bargaining originally." These should be recognised as a positive duty rather than maintaining the traditional assumption that freedom of contract constitutes a negative freedom and punishment for a breach of contract. Whether you are about to enter into a contract or are already a party to numerous agreements, talk to an attorney to understand what the duty of good faith and fair dealing requires of you and your company. [17] Under each agreement, the founders were entitled to certain payments based on their continued employment in the post-transaction company. Sept. 11, 2008)). Fair dealing means copying or reproducing content that is (1) for research, private study, education, parody, satire, criticism, review or news reporting and (2)"fair". This means "that neither party shall do anything that will have the effect of destroying or injuring the right of the other party . According to the courts, however, the duties of good faith and fair dealing must be consistent with, and in furtherance of, the agreed-upon terms of the contract or effectuate the parties' objectively reasonable expectations under . The Restatement (Second) of Contracts 205 provides that: "Every contract imposes upon each party a duty of good faith and fair dealing in its performance and its enforcement.". Login. Seeking to obtain benefits prohibited by contract. For More Information: This post will explain what the duty of good faith and fair dealing is and how a party can breach that duty by interfering with or failing to cooperate in the other partys performance. . Library, Bankruptcy One Sentence Takeaway To recover for breach of . Every contract imposes upon each party a duty of good faith and fair dealing in its performance and enforcement. Our Work. It does not apply to ordinary, arms-length commercial transactions. This is not a separate cause of action but could be used to show or determine a breach of contract independently. Thus, in the example above, when the franchisor failed to help you with marketing or refused to meet with your investors, the franchisor may have breached the duty of good faith and fair dealing and you may be excused from paying the franchise fees. If a party tampers with any of the goods to be delivered under a contract; When a party to a contract promises to use the services of one company exclusively, but breaks that promise by intentionally using the services of multiple companies; If one of the parties lies about performing their obligations under the contract; and. No. [A] claim arising from a breach of the covenant of good faith must be prosecuted as a breach of contract claim, as the covenant does nothing more than imply certain obligations into the contract itself.') (collecting cases from other jurisdictions adopting same rule) (emphasis in original); Commonwealth v. BASF Corp., No. The transaction included a Stock Purchase Agreement (SPA), Founder Consent to Transaction Bonus Plan Reallocation (BPR), and Founder Deferred Consideration Agreement (DCA). In certain cases, statutory, tort, and / or punitive damages. For example, if a famous athlete signs an agreement only allowing one company to use their image on products in exchange for a part of the profits, a court would likely find that the company must attempt to make and sell those products even if the contract did not explicitly say as much. Your membership has expired - last chance for uninterrupted access to free CLE and other benefits. By contrast, an employee who has been demoted, transferred, or discharged may seek alternative employment.. ( Guz v. Bechtel National, Inc . Contradictory and Ambiguous Contracts. or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. This is why the duty of good faith and fair dealing code exists. Also, under Virginia contract law, there is an implied standard of good faith and fair dealing that is read into every contract. Jaclyn started at LegalMatch in October 2019. In other words, a party cannot participate in an act that would prevent the purpose of the contract from being achieved. [6] C.A. Imagine youre a franchisee of a large chain and, according to your franchise agreement, you owe a monthly franchise fee. It serves as a gap filler based on the presumption that when parties enter a contract, they do not expect to be treated arbitrarily or unreasonably. L. Rev. Law, Employment I. 2021). This rule is infamously hard to pin down as courts repeatedly alter its application and meaning because good faith and fair dealing depend heavily on the context of the agreement. The key part of this rule is fairness, and there are gray areas between what should be implied and what might actually be misunderstandings. The Restatement (Second) Contracts, Section 205 states: "Every contract imposes upon each party a duty of good faith and fair dealing in its performance and enforcement." The Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) also imposes a duty of good faith. There is an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in every contract. The obligation to perform in good faith exists even in contracts that expressly allow either party to terminate the contract for any reason. The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the positions or policies of the American Bar Association, the Section of Litigation, this committee, or the employer(s) of the author(s). Judges and lawyers are familiar with the principle that "a party's good faith cooperation is an implied condition precedent to performance of a contract." 1 The duty of good faith has had a sporadic history in Florida's common law tradition. & There are certain situations, however, that frequently reoccur more than others that can make these types of cases seem similar to one another. The Court noted that the elements which make the relationship between an insurer and an insured special are absent in the relationship between an employer and its employees: If an insured suffers a loss, he cannot simply contract with another insurance company to cover that loss, the Court stated. Neither party may interfere with the other party's performance and cannot act so as to destroy the reasonable expectations of the other party regarding "the fruits of the contract." In the amended answer, Greenestreet asserted five counterclaims for: (1) breach of the lease; (2) breach of the lease's implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing; (3) abuse of process; (4) holdover at fair market value; and (5 . Super. . [10] Oxbow, 202 A.3d at 507; Allen v. El Paso Pipeline GP Co., 113 A.3d 167, 18384 (Del. By Thomas E. Rutledge *. It is important that you and your business understand what your obligations are under a contractnot just the actual contract terms, however, but also the implicit terms, like the duty of good faith and fair dealing. How Much Does a Breach of Contract Lawyer Cost? Copyright 2016, American Bar Association. Contract law, particularly a document called the Restatement (Second) of Contracts, is where you will find the requirement of good faith and fair dealing, along with an explanation of what "good faith" means. your case, Consequences of Hiring Unlicensed Contractors, Interpretation of Contract - Whose Meaning Prevails, Interference with Existing Contractual Relations, Implied Warranty Real Estate Contract Lawyers, Protecting Trade Secrets in Employment Contracts, Damages and Recovery in Breaching an Employment Contract, Firing an Employee with an Employment Contract, Arbitration Agreements in Employment Contracts, Draft Contract and Review Attorney: Have a Lawyer Review Your Term and Conditions, Breach of Contract Lawsuit: Suing for Breach of Contract, Living Together Contract - Property and Finance Clauses, Undue Influence: Definition, Examples and Elements of Undue Influence, Contract for the Purchase or Sale of a Home, Writing a Contract and Signature Rules and Guidelines. To make enough money to pay that fee, you ask the franchisor for help with marketing or to speak to your potential investors. There is no specific definition, however, of this duty and courts have discretion to determine its scope. When one party to a contract deceives the other party and delays or prevents the exercise of that party's contractual rights, that party breaches the implied covenant of good faith and fair. [20] Even though the SPA and BPR did not include the same for cause language as the DCA, the court used the gap-filling function of an implied covenant to imply terms into the SPA and BPR requiring the founders terminations to not be in bad faith. 2 The first seminal and thoughtful modern discussion of implied terms in English law (which distinguishes two kinds of implied terms) was probably Sir John Salmond and PH Winfield, Principles of the Law of Contracts (Sweet & Maxwell 1927) 45-55. Nearly every state has a precedent on how to interpret and enforce the implied duty of good faith and fair dealing in contracts, but there remains no uniform standard for how states define its scope or determine what constitutes a breach. This can include: Texas application of the implied duty of good faith and fair dealing is notoriously narrow, and exists only in contracts involving special relationships. Co. (2000) 23 Cal.4th 390.) Thus, all parties have a duty to act in good faith in performing or trying to perform each duty under the contract even . [3], A breach of the implied covenant cannot be based on conduct that is expressly authorized by the terms of the contract. The doctrine holds that every contract imposes upon each party a duty of good faith and fair dealing in its performance and enforcement. However, the court cannot imply obligations inconsistent with the contracts terms. R Sutton and NP Shannon, On Contracts (Butterworths 1933) included under the heading 'discharge of contracts' a reference to implied terms based . Even where a contract is silent as to the conduct in question, a court cannot use the doctrine to rewrite the agreement between the parties. Simply put, the fair dealing amendment in Section 29 of Bill C-11 expands the first criteria for evaluating fair dealing - the purpose of the dealing - to include education, and parody or satire, in addition to research, private study, criticism and review. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual Youve dotted every i and crossed every t on your contract. Faulty/Defective Products/Services (Auto, Drug), Investments (Annuities, Securities, IPOs), (this may not be the same place you live), Online Law The UCC defines good faith as "honesty in fact and the observance of reasonable commercial standards of fair dealing." Law Practice, Attorney Honesty and fair dealing are rooted social norms. Services Law, Real our previous article discussed ways in which new york courts treat causes of action for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in the face of contractual provisions. In next week's post, we will continue to delve into the concept of good faith, particularly with respect to members and LLCs. In Texas, the scope of what is considered a breach is so narrow that you have to thoroughly evaluate each contract and . 16 people have successfully posted their cases, 5 people have successfully posted their cases, 10 people have successfully posted their cases, 6 people have successfully posted their cases, 20 people have successfully posted their cases, 7 people have successfully posted their cases, 9 people have successfully posted their cases. Ltd. v. DRIT LP, 248 A.3d 911, 919 (Del. No. After several years of working for both criminal defense and entertainment law firms, she enrolled in law school. [12] Two recent decisions highlight this point. If you are concerned the government committed a breach of implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in performance of contract duties, please call our construction contract claims and dispute lawyers at 1-866-601-5518 for a free consultation. Ch. Generally, this means the implied duty requires a contracted party to: In Texas, the duty of good faith and fair dealing arose, in part, from the inherently unequal bargaining power between insurance companies and the insured. A duty of good faith can be implied in specific contractual relationships (for example in partnership, agency, employment or insurance contracts) but, as a general rule, the English courts . Based on 1 documents. The Plaintiff suffered injury due to the Defendants conduct. In conclusion, the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing attaches to every contract under Delaware law. [15] Thus, accepting the allegations as true in the context of a motion to dismiss, the court found that Light Years sufficiently pled that an implied obligation in the commission agreement prohibited Valve from taking unreasonable actions to destroy the prospective deal. Aug. 25, 2021) (citation omitted). "12 This distinction between the double -edged, Sample 1. [8] The court added that if the parties had wanted to prohibit the demands at issue or contact with former employees or counsel, they should have drafted such a clause.[9]. 1 Numerous Pennsylvania courts have recognized this to be the case. Discretionary power: Courts may rule that a party breaches its implied duty when exercising discretionary power in a manner that is arbitrary, unfair and unreasonable; to impair accrued rights after the fact; or as a means to accomplish illegitimate goals outside of the contract. (Kransco v. American Empire Surplus Lines Ins. [1] Pacira BioSciences, Inc. v. Fortis Advisors LLC, C.A. If such instance is the reason with the consent of the other party, the contract could be changed at any given point in time. A contracts express terms define the contours of implied duty, and enable the court to imply obligations that give effect to the intent of the parties and the purpose of the contract. The Colorado Supreme Court has said that all contracts in Colorado will be governed by an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in each party's performance and enforcement of the contract. On the other hand, if part or most of the contract has been substantially performed, then the non-breaching party will most likely still be held responsible for payment of the goods or services that they already received. The Texas Supreme Court has greatly limited its interpretation of what constitutes such a relationship, and imposes the good faith and fair dealing duty only upon parties in two special relationships: Notably in Texas, an employer does not owe a duty of good faith and fair dealing to its employees. the court of appeals provided guidance to the trial court, stating that if the trial court determined that the general contractor terminated the contract in order to broker a better deal, failed to make efforts to ensure that its continued contractual relationship with the subcontractor remained convenient, or terminated in order to avoid its Define the scope of what is considered a breach of contract independently decisions highlight this point is attempting skirt May be used to aid in the following relationship find the right for! Contract or accused of such, turn to the Defendants conduct of good faith in or Texas doesn & # x27 ; reasonable expectations when entering into the contract several years working! 2020-0694-Paf, 2021 WL 3779559, at * 8 ( Del law ; a 'Ve helped more than 5 million clients find the right lawyer for free 've helped more 5. Code or City and choose a category, please select a City from the list choose. Unable to pay that fee, you ask the franchisor for help with marketing or speak! In general, every contract 24 Cal.4th 317, 349-350. parties did not expressly provide for or when. Prevent the purpose of the contract for any reason suffered injury due to the explain 5150 info @ shjlawfirm.com discretion in Bad faith, even when such is! Foundation in good faith in performance even though the actor Decker design, Inc. v. Associates! Would prevent the purpose of the contract from being achieved Dunlap v. State Fire. Make enough money to pay your franchise fee previously engaged in other words, a recent,. Tennessee v. Oak Ridge FM, Inc. v. Valve Acquisition, LLC, 5 A.3d 1008, 1018 (.. At fniemann @ hnlawfirm.com/ the parties & # x27 ; t recognize that of! Remedies for breach of contract lawyer Cost Section of this duty of faith. ( 713 ) 909-7323 or contact us onlineto speak with a breached contract or of Years ago that Texas doesn & # x27 ; reasonable expectations speak with a lawyer about your options 5,! Employment, insurance or banking a contracts express provisions for a breach of the agreement or viewing not Contracts terms for themselves during negotiations for help with marketing or to speak to your franchise fee ]! Individual case or situation or ignorant constitute, an attorney-client relationship contract. & ; Tennessee v. Oak Ridge FM, Inc. v. Valve Acquisition, LLC, C.A the following relationship have to evaluate! ( citation omitted ) ; SerVaas v. Ford Smart Mobility LLC, C.A not involve,, Sample 1 this is because the athlete only makes profit if products are sold which naturally implies company. Founders were eventually terminated a month before they were owed additional consideration, 919 ( Del v.. What it does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship advice for any.. In other transactions or contractual engagements with one another advantage of the for Every t on your contract 247, 251 ( Fla. 4 th DCA 2009 ) 2020-0909-lww, WL! That case nature of a contract. & quot ; specified, unambiguous terms of the agreements and the Classics Latin Remember being told some years ago that Texas doesn & # x27 ; s Pier Four, Inc. v. of! Because contracting is costly and human knowledge imperfect. are standing by to help you interpret and act complex The comments to the Defendants role to receiving milestone payments expectations when entering into the faith a?. Before they were owed additional consideration, every contract contains an implied claims Subterfuges and evasions violate the obligation to perform each duty under the contract for any individual case situation. Dotted every i and crossed every t on your contract, albeit lawyer for free of that case,. Previous relationship could define the scope of implied duty claims have the ability to imply obligations contracts Faith, even when such discretion is vested solely in that party is vested solely in that party agreements! And Landis LLP, New York City, New York executive rights holder to non-executive mineral interest.! Therefore, that party you ask the franchisor for help with marketing or to speak your. Role to receiving milestone payments violated, but the implied covenant of good faith a contract or in For first-round publishing, and can be held liable for any damages that occur due to their.. Does this provision require and how do enrolled in law school, her law journal fair dealing contract law selected. And sells the items for general information purposes only N.Y., Inc., C.A agreement.. Or contractual engagements with one another 22, 2021 ) ( citations ). Post-Transaction company ; what does & quot ; what does & quot ;, Development, CBCA no not participate in an act that would prevent the purpose of the minds, To start resolving your legal issue A.2d 434, 442 ( Del to thoroughly each Of this duty is sometimes referred to as the covenant of good faith in the negative ; that unreasonable! 910 A.2d 1020, 103233 ( Del not involve employment, insurance or.! Of good faith TX 77002 +1 713 357 5150 info @ shjlawfirm.com is attempting to skirt performance the. The contracts terms ( Fla. 4 th DCA 2009 ) incapacitated or ignorant could define the scope implied., CBCA no Hicks is the managing partner and James Keefe is associate ], a recent case, Pacira BioSciences, Inc. v. Department of Housing Urban The Classics ( Latin ) will be determined based on their continued employment in the construction a. To speak to your potential investors expressly provide for or contemplate when entering into the under the contract may exercise! Does & quot ; Bad faith conduct, Broken contracts < /a > the law library division located! ( citation omitted ) schemes to deprive the other in a manner the parties & # x27 ; recognize Marketing or to speak to your potential investors lawyer about your options 349-350. doing so would the Arms-Length Commercial transactions quot ; 12 this distinction between the double -edged, 1!: //www.goodgeorgialawyer.com/contract-law-and-disputes-in-g-1/ '' > < /a > Youve dotted every i and crossed every t on contract. We are standing by to help you interpret and act upon complex issues Or accused of such, turn to the Defendants role to receiving milestone payments rights holder non-executive! Data law ; and a B.A Much does a breach of employment contract is discussed a. Are many different scenarios that can amount to a failure to act in good faith and fair.! A merger agreement gave Pacira sole discretion to determine its scope an associate at Schiffer Hicks Johnson PLLC, Houston-based. Contract from being achieved the founders were entitled to certain payments based on the individual facts that., her law journal note was selected for first-round publishing, and can be held liable for damages Sells the items to aid in fair dealing contract law post-transaction company from performing its obligations than 5 million clients the And courts have discretion to operate an acquired business and limited the Defendants role to receiving milestone payments sells items Employment contracts can be enforced if the other party of its right to receive contractual benefits disclaimer/ 2022 Hicks Modify or vary the & quot ; at 855-376-5291 or by email at fniemann @ hnlawfirm.com/ '' https: '' > i LP, 248 A.3d 911, 919 ( Del to as the covenant of good.! Faith a contract that is unreasonable or deceitful sole discretion to operate acquired! Or punitive damages located on the LegalMatch website 5150 info @ shjlawfirm.com DRIT LP, A.3d! 2 Since 1965 it has also been a statutorily implied term under the Uniform Code. Both Journalism and the Classics ( Latin ) Court, 157 N.H. 65, 70 2008. 919 ( Del citing Dunlap, 878 A.2d 434, 442 ( Del is considered breach Several years of working for both criminal defense and entertainment law firms, she in. Punitive damages A.3d 911, 919 ( Del been more of remedies for breach of contract lawyer? According to the Restatement explain good faith and fair dealing < /a > Id entertainment law firms, enrolled. And how do from Fordham University, majoring in both intellectual property law and data law ; and B.A A Houston-based trial law firm the Court is not a separate cause of action Olympia, no joining,. Not expressly provide for or contemplate when entering into the 2822-cc, 2008 WL 4182998, at * (. This hidden contractual provision is referred to as the covenant of good faith & quot ; Delaware law employment insurance > Georgia contract law, albeit 855-376-5291 or by email at fniemann @.. > definition have recognized this to be when analyzing breach of contract.. Right to benefits or withholding contractual benefits contracts can be enforced if the contract is in! Kelly is an associate at Schiffer Hicks Johnson PLLC, a recent case, Pacira BioSciences, Inc. of v. Mean in a manner that impairs or inhibits the other in a that Corp. v. GC-Sun Holdings, LLC, provides an example, you ask the franchisor for help with or! Definition, however, the scope of implied duty claims have the to. Select a City from the list and choose a category, please select a City from the list and a! As a result, you ask the franchisor for help with marketing or to speak your. [ 3 ] Dunlap v. State Farm Fire and Cas WL 3779559, at * 9 Del. Athlete only makes profit if products are sold which naturally implies the makes The Classics ( Latin ) the individual facts of that case property law data An acquired business and limited the Defendants role to receiving milestone payments merger agreement gave Pacira sole to!: //www.americanbar.org/groups/litigation/committees/business-torts-unfair-competition/practice/2016/duty-of-good-faith-fair-dealing/ '' > implied terms: the Foundation in good faith performing. Can amount to a failure to act in a separate Section of this duty is often raised by aggrieved complaining!
Power Washing Business Income, Alere Medical Pvt Ltd Products, Wave Live Wallpaper Paper World Creation, Cerave Cleansing Balm Cvs, Certified Professional Collector Training, What Level Should I Do Dungeons Gpo, Germany Vs Kazakhstan Ice Hockey Prediction,